The World Health Organization has walked back a top officials claim that asymptomatic spread of coronavirus is “very rare” after it sparked controversy and confusion worldwide.
The remarks Monday by epidemiologist Maria Van Kerkhove — the WHOs technical lead on the pandemic — contradicted advice given by health experts and policymakers in most countries, who have based calls for social distancing and mask wearing on the idea that people without symptoms can unwittingly spread infection.
Van Kerkhove said Tuesday that she had been misunderstood and her remarks were based on just two to three preliminary scientific studies. But experts worry the episode could undermine WHO at a crucial moment in the global coronavirus response.
“Its an unfortunate misstep in the middle of whats already a hard road for most public health officials,” said Nahid Bhadelia, an infectious disease physician and the medical director of the Special Pathogens Unit at the Boston University School of Medicine.
The controversy comes at a tumultuous time for the WHO. U.S. President Donald Trump said last month blasted the agencys coronavirus response and said the U.S. would withdraw its support. A Trump administration official confirmed U.S. funding to the WHO has been suspended.
Several prominent Republicans jumped on Van Kerkhoves initial statements as evidence the United States could safely, and completely, reopen. “Good News! People who catch coronovirus but have no symptoms rarely spread the disease. Translation: sending kids back to school does not require millions of test kits,” Republican Senator Rand Paul tweeted on Monday. His tweet has been shared more than 11,000 times and liked at least 25,000 times as of Tuesday afternoon.
During a briefing Tuesday, van Kerkhove said the extent to which asymptomatic people spread the virus is a “big open question,” although there is evidence showing it does happen. Some disease-modeling studies suggest that asymptomatic spread accounts for 40 percent of all infections, she said.
That does not include the risk posed by presymptomatic people, who can infect others before they develop any symptoms of the virus. By contrast, asymptomatic people carry the virus without ever developing signs of the disease.
Van Kerkhove also said her initial statements were based on unpublished contact-tracing data collected by some WHO member countries.
Public health advocates and experts panned her decision to cite research that isnt publicly available.
“Theres so much attention to everything thats being said by every public health agency that its important to be extremely careful and science-based in what you say,” said Tom Frieden, who served as CDC director during the Obama administration.
And Andy Slavitt, who led the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services under former President Barack Obama, also criticized the WHO official. “If your data is thin or not public or contradicted by lots of studies, making definitive statements is a mistake,” he tweeted.
Read More – Source
The World Health Organization has walked back a top officials claim that asymptomatic spread of coronavirus is “very rare” after it sparked controversy and confusion worldwide.
The remarks Monday by epidemiologist Maria Van Kerkhove — the WHOs technical lead on the pandemic — contradicted advice given by health experts and policymakers in most countries, who have based calls for social distancing and mask wearing on the idea that people without symptoms can unwittingly spread infection.
Van Kerkhove said Tuesday that she had been misunderstood and her remarks were based on just two to three preliminary scientific studies. But experts worry the episode could undermine WHO at a crucial moment in the global coronavirus response.
“Its an unfortunate misstep in the middle of whats already a hard road for most public health officials,” said Nahid Bhadelia, an infectious disease physician and the medical director of the Special Pathogens Unit at the Boston University School of Medicine.
The controversy comes at a tumultuous time for the WHO. U.S. President Donald Trump said last month blasted the agencys coronavirus response and said the U.S. would withdraw its support. A Trump administration official confirmed U.S. funding to the WHO has been suspended.
Several prominent Republicans jumped on Van Kerkhoves initial statements as evidence the United States could safely, and completely, reopen. “Good News! People who catch coronovirus but have no symptoms rarely spread the disease. Translation: sending kids back to school does not require millions of test kits,” Republican Senator Rand Paul tweeted on Monday. His tweet has been shared more than 11,000 times and liked at least 25,000 times as of Tuesday afternoon.
During a briefing Tuesday, van Kerkhove said the extent to which asymptomatic people spread the virus is a “big open question,” although there is evidence showing it does happen. Some disease-modeling studies suggest that asymptomatic spread accounts for 40 percent of all infections, she said.
That does not include the risk posed by presymptomatic people, who can infect others before they develop any symptoms of the virus. By contrast, asymptomatic people carry the virus without ever developing signs of the disease.
Van Kerkhove also said her initial statements were based on unpublished contact-tracing data collected by some WHO member countries.
Public health advocates and experts panned her decision to cite research that isnt publicly available.
“Theres so much attention to everything thats being said by every public health agency that its important to be extremely careful and science-based in what you say,” said Tom Frieden, who served as CDC director during the Obama administration.
And Andy Slavitt, who led the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services under former President Barack Obama, also criticized the WHO official. “If your data is thin or not public or contradicted by lots of studies, making definitive statements is a mistake,” he tweeted.
Read More – Source
