Tuesday, June 3, 2025
Germany Latest News
  • Sports
  • USA
  • Asia
  • Health
  • Life Style
  • Tech
  • Science
  • Latin America
  • Africa
  • Europe
No Result
View All Result
Germany Latest News

Amazon facial recognition thinks 28 Congressmen look like known criminals — at default settings – CNET

by The Editor
July 27, 2018
in Science
0
Amazon facial recognition thinks 28 Congressmen look like known criminals — at default settings     – CNET
Chris Monroe/CNET

Amazon is trying to sell its Rekognition facial recognition technology to law enforcment, but the American Civil Liberties Union doesn't think that's a very good idea. And today, the ACLU provided some seemingly compelling evidence — by using Amazon's own tool to compare 2,500 criminal mugshots to members of Congress.

Sure enough, Amazon's tool thought 28 different members of Congress looked like people who've been arrested.

Related posts

Can Misinfo Harm Science?

Can Misinfo Harm Science?

February 7, 2023
Climate change: World aviation agrees ‘aspirational’ net zero plan

Climate change: World aviation agrees ‘aspirational’ net zero plan

October 8, 2022
false-matches-graphic-1false-matches-graphic-1
ACLU

Here's the full list, according to the ACLU:

Senate

  • Johnny Isakson (R-Georgia)
  • Ed Markey (D-Massachusetts)
  • Pat Roberts (R-Kansas)

House

  • Sanford Bishop (D-Georgia)
  • G. K. Butterfield (D-North Carolina)
  • Lacy Clay (D-Missouri)
  • Mark DeSaulnier (D-California)
  • Adriano Espaillat (D-New York)
  • Ruben Gallego (D-Arizona)
  • Tom Garrett (R-Virginia)
  • Greg Gianforte (R-Montana)
  • Jimmy Gomez (D-California)
  • Raúl Grijalva (D-Arizona)
  • Luis Gutiérrez (D-Illinois)
  • Steve Knight (R-California)
  • Leonard Lance (R-New Jersey)
  • John Lewis (D-Georgia)
  • Frank LoBiondo (R-New Jersey)
  • Dave Loebsack (D-Iowa)
  • David McKinley (R-West Virginia)
  • John Moolenaar (R-Michigan)
  • Tom Reed (R-New York)
  • Bobby Rush (D-Illinois)
  • Norma Torres (D-California)
  • Marc Veasey (D-Texas)
  • Brad Wenstrup (R-Ohio)
  • Steve Womack (R-Arkansas)
  • Lee Zeldin (R-New York)

That's a lot of Congresspeople who may soon have some very valid questions about facial recognition and its potential to be abused — particularly since Amazon thinks the ACLU didn't use it properly to begin with!

It turns out that the ACLU got its mugshot matches by using the Rekognition software at its default 80-percent confidence threshold setting, rather than the 95-percent plus confidence level that Amazon recommends for law enforcement agencies.

"While 80 percent confidence is an acceptable threshold for photos of hot dogs, chairs, animals, or other social media use cases, it wouldn't be appropriate for identifying individuals with a reasonable level of certainty. When using facial recognition for law enforcement activities, we guide customers to set a threshold of at least 95 percent or higher," an Amazon spokesperson told CNET by email.

But an ACLU lawyer tells CNET that Amazon doesn't necessarily steer law enforcement agencies toward that higher threshold — if a police department uses the software, it'll be set to the same 80-percent threshold by default and won't ask them to change it even if they intend to use it to identify criminals. "Amazon makes no effort to ask users what they are using Rekognition for," says ACLU attorney Jacob Snow.

employee-verificationemployee-verification

The ACLU says that even when it comes to facial recognition for security purposes, Amazon's website suggests that the 80-percent confidence threshold is sufficent.

Screenshot by ACLU

A source close to the matter tells CNET that when Amazon works with law enforcment agencies directly, like the Orlando Police Department, it teaches them how to reduce false positives and avoid human bias. But there's nothing to necessarily keep other agencies from simply using the tool the same way the ACLU did, instead of developing a relationship with Amazon.

It's worth noting that false positives are (currently!) an accepted part of facial recognition technology. Nobody — including the ACLU — is saying police would arrest or (God forbid) shoot someone based on a false match alone. Facial recognition narrows down the list of suspects, and then humans take over. Recently, facial recognition helped ID the Russian assassins who poisoned a spy in the UK, as well as the Capital Gazette shooter.

And Amazon didn't actually create that many false positives even at the 80 percent confidence ratio, compared to, say, the UK Metropolitan Police's facial recognition tech.

But the ACLU worries that Amazon's false positives might bias a police officer or government agent to search, question or potentially draw a weapon when they shouldn't — and we've all seen how those encounters can turn deadly.

The ACLU also provided CNET this statement:

Amazon seems to have missed, or refuses to acknowledge, the broader point: facial recognition technology in the hands of government is primed for abuse and raises significant civil rights concerns. It could allow – and in some cases has already enabled – police to determine who attends protests, ICE to continuously monitor immigrants, and cities to routinely track their own residents, whether they have reason to suspect criminal activity or not. Changing the threshold from 80 to 95 percent doesn't change that. In fact, it could exacerbate it.

Should Congress regulate facial recognition? Microsoft thinks so, and now 28 members of Congress have some very personal food for thought — 95-percent confidence threshold or no.

Update, 11:07 a.m. PT: Two of the Congressmen who were mismatched with mugshots, Reps. Jimmy Gomez and John Lewis, have requested an immediate meeting with Amazon CEO Jeff Bezos to "address the defects" of its facial recognition technology, according to an official letter obtained by BuzzFeed News.

Previous Post

Who’s the best wireless carrier in the US? – CNET

Next Post

A star orbiting a black hole shows Einstein got gravity right — again

Next Post
A star orbiting a black hole shows Einstein got gravity right — again

A star orbiting a black hole shows Einstein got gravity right — again

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

RECOMMENDED NEWS

8 Recent Artifact Discoveries That Surprised the World

8 Recent Artifact Discoveries That Surprised the World

7 years ago
Girls’ Generation star Hyoyeon went into DJ-ing to challenge herself

Girls’ Generation star Hyoyeon went into DJ-ing to challenge herself

5 years ago
Marked for life: South Korea’s tattoo artists seek legalisation

Marked for life: South Korea’s tattoo artists seek legalisation

5 years ago

20 dead kids shaped this senator’s mission

7 years ago

FOLLOW US

  • 139 Followers
  • 87.2k Followers
  • 202k Subscribers

BROWSE BY CATEGORIES

  • 1xbet Casino Russia
  • 1xbet Russian Top
  • Africa
  • AI
  • Asia
  • Europe
  • Health
  • latest news
  • Latin America
  • Life Style
  • Mail Order Brides
  • Mostbet
  • Online dating
  • onlyfans
  • Pin Up
  • Pin Up Russia
  • Science
  • Sports
  • Tech
  • Uncategorized
  • USA

BROWSE BY TOPICS

2018 League Bali United Beijing BlackBerry Brazil Broja Budget Travel Bundesliga California Champions League Chelsea China Chopper Bike Coronavirus COVID COVID-19 Crime Doctor Terawan EU France French German Istana Negara Italy Kazakhstan Market Stories Mexico National Exam Nigeria Omicron Pakistan Police protests Qatar Ronaldo Russia Smart Voting Sweden TikTok Trump UK Ukraine US vaccine Visit Bali
No Result
View All Result

Recent Posts

  • AI Girlfriends as Creative Writing Partners
  • OnlyFans Platform Analysis
  • How to Day German Fashion
  • Southeast Continental Capabilities
  • What is a Mail Order Wife?

Categories

  • 1xbet Casino Russia
  • 1xbet Russian Top
  • Africa
  • AI
  • Asia
  • Europe
  • Health
  • latest news
  • Latin America
  • Life Style
  • Mail Order Brides
  • Mostbet
  • Online dating
  • onlyfans
  • Pin Up
  • Pin Up Russia
  • Science
  • Sports
  • Tech
  • Uncategorized
  • USA

Tags

2018 League Bali United Beijing BlackBerry Brazil Broja Budget Travel Bundesliga California Champions League Chelsea China Chopper Bike Coronavirus COVID COVID-19 Crime Doctor Terawan EU France French German Istana Negara Italy Kazakhstan Market Stories Mexico National Exam Nigeria Omicron Pakistan Police protests Qatar Ronaldo Russia Smart Voting Sweden TikTok Trump UK Ukraine US vaccine Visit Bali
Federal Government focuses on “integrated security”
latest news

Federal Government focuses on “integrated security”

by The Editor
June 14, 2023
0

Berlin (dpa) – The Federal Government is responding to the challenges of an increasingly unstable world order by means of a “policy...

Read more

Recent News

  • AI Girlfriends as Creative Writing Partners
  • OnlyFans Platform Analysis
  • How to Day German Fashion

Category

  • 1xbet Casino Russia
  • 1xbet Russian Top
  • Africa
  • AI
  • Asia
  • Europe
  • Health
  • latest news
  • Latin America
  • Life Style
  • Mail Order Brides
  • Mostbet
  • Online dating
  • onlyfans
  • Pin Up
  • Pin Up Russia
  • Science
  • Sports
  • Tech
  • Uncategorized
  • USA

Recent News

AI Girlfriends as Creative Writing Partners

May 30, 2025

OnlyFans Platform Analysis

June 12, 2024
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Contact

© 2025 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.

No Result
View All Result
  • Sports
  • USA
  • Asia
  • Health
  • Life Style
  • Tech
  • Science
  • Latin America
  • Africa
  • Europe

© 2025 JNews - Premium WordPress news & magazine theme by Jegtheme.